-- Last updated Nov. 26, 2013, for Week 14 vs. Penn State
| OFFENSE | ||
| FIRST TEAM | SECOND TEAM | |
| QB | 2 Joel Stave (So.) | 10 Curt Phillips (Sr.) |
| RB | 20 James White (Sr.) | 25 Melvin Gordon (So.) |
| FB | 34 Derek Watt (So.) | 26 Derek Straus (So.) |
| WR | 4 Jared Abbrederis (Sr.) | 86 Alex Erickson (Fr.) |
| WR | 9 Jordan Fredrick (So.) | 3 Kenzel Doe (Jr.) |
| TE | 48 Jacob Pedersen (Sr.) | 49 Sam Arneson (Jr.) |
| TE | 85 Brian Wozniak (Sr.) | 81 Brock DeCicco (Sr.) |
| LT | 61 Tyler Marz (So.) | 74 Hayden Biegel (Fr.) |
| LG | 79 Ryan Groy (Sr.) | 71 Ray Ball (So.) |
| C | 73 Dallas Lewallen (Jr.) | 70 Dan Voltz (Fr.) |
| RG | 54 Kyle Costigan (Jr.) | 75 Zac Matthias (Sr.) |
| RT | 78 Rob Havenstein (Jr.) | 62 Walker Williams (Fr.) |
| DEFENSE | ||
| FIRST TEAM | SECOND TEAM | |
| DL | 92 Pat Muldoon (Sr.) OR 51 Tyler Dippel (Sr.) | |
| NT | 96 Beau Allen (Sr.) | 45 Warren Herring (Jr.) |
| DL | 87 Ethan Hemer (Sr.) | 91 Konrad Zagzebski (Jr.) |
| OLB | 36 Ethan Armstrong (Sr.) | 58 Joe Schobert (So.) |
| ILB | 44 Chris Borland (Sr.) | 59 Marcus Trotter (Jr.) |
| ILB | 30 Derek Landisch (Jr.) OR 13 Conor O'Neill (Sr.) | |
| OLB | 97 Brendan Kelly (Sr.) | 47 Vince Biegel (So.) |
| CB | 8 Sojourn Shelton (Fr.) | 9 Jakarrie Washington (Fr.) |
| SS | 12 Dezmen Southward (Sr.) | 14 Nate Hammon (Fr.) OR 17 Tanner McEvoy (So.) |
| FS | 7 Michael Caputo (So.) | 19 Leo Musso (Fr.) |
| CB | 21 Peniel Jean (Jr.) | 11 T.J. Reynard (So.) |
| NB | 5 Darius Hillary (So.) | |
| SPECIAL TEAMS | ||
| FIRST TEAM | SECOND TEAM | |
| P | 90 Drew Meyer (So.) | 96 Stephen Salata (So.) |
| K (FG) | 17 Jack Russell (So.) | 94 Kyle French (Jr.) |
| KO | 85 Andrew Endicott (Fr.) | 94 Kyle French (Jr.) |
| LS | 56 James McGuire (Jr.) | 60 Connor Udelhoven (Fr.) |
| H | 90 Drew Meyer (So.) | 96 Stephen Salata (So.) |
| PR | 3 Kenzel Doe (Jr.) OR 4 Jared Abbrederis (Sr.) |
9 Jordan Fredrick (So.) |
| KR | 3 Kenzel Doe (Jr.) | 27 Kyle Zuleger (Sr.) |